Analysis: Trump Proud Boys remark echoes Charlottesville

President Donald Trump on Wednesday tried to walk back his refusal to condemn a far-right group during his debate with Democrat Joe Biden, but the inflammatory moment was far from the first time the president has failed to denounce white supremacists or has advanced racist ideas.

Trump’s initial refusal to criticise the Proud Boys – instead saying the group should “stand back and stand by” – drew fierce blowback before he altered his message in an effort to quell the firestorm a day later.

“I don’t know who Proud Boys are. But whoever they are they have to stand down, let law enforcement do their work,” Trump told reporters as he left the White House for a campaign stop in Minnesota.

The new flare-up over Trump’s messaging on race was playing out just weeks before the election, leaving the president to play defence on yet another issue when he is already facing criticism of his handling of the coronavirus pandemic and under new scrutiny over his taxes.

And even after saying the Proud Boys should “stand down,” Trump went on to call out forces on the other end of the political spectrum and tried to attack Biden. It was an echo of the way he had blamed “both sides” for the 2017 violence between white supremacists and anti-racist protesters in Charlottesville, Virginia.

“Now antifa is a real problem,” Trump said. “The problem is on the left. And Biden refuses to talk about it.”

In fact, FBI Director Christopher Wray told a congressional panel last week that it was white supremacists and anti-government extremists who have been responsible for most of the recent deadly attacks by extremist groups in the United States.

‘That’s not who we are’

Proud Boys leaders and supporters took to social media to celebrate the president’s comments at the debate, with more than 5,000 of the group’s members posting “Stand Back” and “Stand By” above and below the group’s logo.

And when Trump was directly asked on Wednesday if he “would welcome white supremacist support,” he ignored the question and again stressed the need for “law and order”.

The president has rarely condemned white supremacists when not pressed to do so, and his refusal to criticise the fascist group was denounced by Democrats on Wednesday.

“My message to the Proud Boys and every other white supremacist group is cease and desist,” Biden said during a post-debate train tour through Ohio and Pennsylvania. “That’s not who we are. That’s not who we are as Americans.”

Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer pressed his Republican colleagues: “How are you not embarrassed that President Trump represents your party? How can you possibly, possibly, support anyone who behaves this way?”

In an ugly debate marked by angry interruptions and bitter asides, Trump’s remarks about the Proud Boys stood out. He was asked by moderator Chris Wallace of Fox News if he would “be willing tonight to condemn white supremacists and militia groups” and demand that they “stand down” and not add to the violence that has erupted in places like Portland, Oregon, and Kenosha, Wisconsin.

The president said “Sure,” but did not offer any actual words of condemnation, instead pivoting to blame the violence on left-wing radicals like antifa supporters. When pushed by Wallace, Trump asked for the name of a group to condemn – and Biden suggested Proud Boys.

“Proud Boys, stand back and stand by,” Trump said.

Few Republicans publicly commented upon the president’s remarks and fewer still criticised them.

GOP House leader Kevin McCarthy insisted Trump did agree when asked if he would condemn the groups, and the California Republican sought to equate the white nationalist groups and the KKK with anti-fascist organisations like antifa.

South Dakota’s GOP Senator Mike Rounds went only so far as to say, “I was hoping for more clarity.”

Senator Tim Scott of South Carolina – the only Black Republican in the Senate – said he believed Trump “misspoke”.

“He should correct it,” Scott added. “If he doesn’t correct it, I guess he didn’t misspeak.”

Biden called Trump a “racist” during the debate. It is a charge that has dogged Trump since his early days as a developer, when he called for the death penalty for the Central Park Five – a group of Black teenagers accused of rape but later cleared – and when he fought charges of bias against Black prospective tenants seeking to rent at his family-owned apartment complexes.

Trump built his political career on the back of the racist lie of “birtherism” – the false claim that Barack Obama was not born in the US. Earlier this year, he briefly wondered if Biden running mate Senator Kamala Harris, whose mother was Indian and father is Jamaican, was eligible to serve as vice president.

Troublesome moments

There have been numerous other racially troublesome moments in recent years.

In his first moments as a presidential candidate, Trump suggested Mexicans were “rapists”. He temporarily banned Muslims from seven countries from the US, stranding people at airports. He retweeted posts from accounts that appeared to have ties to white nationalist groups. He was slow to reject the endorsement of former KKK leader David Duke. And, perhaps most notably, he blamed “both sides” for the violence in Charlottesville that left an anti-racist demonstrator dead.

The debate left some Black Americans dismayed.

“I think he has continued to embolden white supremacists,” said Anne Susen, a 60-year-old unemployed antiques dealer who lives just outside Charlottesville. “He just wants to sow the seeds of division in this country.”

Tori Silver, 22, said there was “no excuse” for Trump not immediately disavowing white supremacist groups.

“It’s kind of like, wow, what is that saying to me as a Black man?” Silver said outside the Albemarle County, Virginia, office where he voted early on Wednesday for Biden.

Proud Boys members are ardent Trump supporters known for their violent confrontations with anti-fascists and other ideological opponents at protests, often drawing large crowds in the Pacific Northwest. Members have been spotted at various Trump rallies, including earlier this month in Nevada.

In 2018, police arrested several Proud Boys members and associates who brawled with antifascists after the group’s founder, Gavin McInnes, delivered a speech at New York’s Metropolitan Republican Club.

McInnes, who co-founded Vice Media, has described the group as a politically incorrect men’s club for “Western chauvinists” and denies affiliations with far-right extremist groups that overtly espouse racist and anti-Semitic views. McInnes sued the Southern Poverty Law Center last year, claiming it defamed him when it designated the Proud Boys as a “hate group”.

In response to the federal suit, which is still pending in Alabama, the law centre said McInnes has acknowledged an “overlap” between the Proud Boys and white nationalist groups.

“Indeed, Proud Boys members have posted social media pictures of themselves with prominent Holocaust deniers, white nationalists, and known neo-Nazis,” law centre lawyers wrote in a court filing.