Singapore says ASEAN not as effective as hoped in Myanmar

Singapore’s Foreign Minister Vivian Balakrishnan says the political situation in Myanmar is ‘dire’ and has vowed to facilitate dialogue and deliver humanitarian help.

Since the coup, Myanmar's economy has collapsed and a humanitarian crisis worsened in the past month as coronavirus infections surged, overwhelming the health system [Stringer via Reuters]

The progress by the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) in Myanmar has not been as effective as hoped, Singapore’s foreign minister said in an interview, as protests and a violent crackdown continue in the country.

The United Nations and many countries have urged ASEAN, whose 10 members include Myanmar, to restore stability through diplomacy.

“(ASEAN is) not as effective or as quick as we would have hoped for. But this is a difficult situation,” Vivian Balakrishnan told Reuters.

In April, ASEAN announced a five-point consensus aimed at resolving the crisis. As part of those efforts, the bloc appointed Brunei’s second minister for foreign affairs as special envoy to Myanmar in early August.

Balakrishnan said he hoped there would be progress to report on the envoy’s visit before the ASEAN leaders’ summit in November. But he cautioned that the military had to grant the envoy access to all stakeholders for the visit to be meaningful.

“The key litmus test now will be how they engage with our special envoy,” Balakrishnan said.

The death toll as a result of Myanmar’s Febuary 1 coup topped 1,000 this week, according to the Assistance Association for Political Prisoners (AAPP) activist group, which has been recording killings by security forces.

Dire humanitarian crisis

Since the coup, Myanmar’s economy has collapsed and a humanitarian crisis worsened in the past month as coronavirus infections surged, overwhelming the health system.

Balakrishnan called the situation “dire” and said ASEAN was trying be constructive, facilitate dialogue and deliver humanitarian assistance.

“We have maintained lines of communication,” Balakrishnan said, when asked whether ASEAN or Singapore had engaged with the shadow National Unity Government. “We’re not trying to make things difficult. And we’re not playing sides. But (military authorities) know we will engage everyone.”

Singapore is small but wields strong economic and political influence in Southeast Asia. Some rights groups say Singapore has leverage in Myanmar thanks to its close ties with the country as one of its biggest investors.

The city-state had a cumulative $24.1bn of investments approved there as of 2020, according to official Myanmar data since 1988. That made it the biggest source of foreign capital there, ahead of China.


However, Balakrishnan said Singapore’s “so-called leverage was overestimated”, because the total also included multinationals that have invested in Myanmar.

He said economic sanctions would affect the people but have a limited effect on the military authorities, who can better withstand isolation.

There has been no discussion within ASEAN about expelling or suspending Myanmar, the minister said, adding that the bloc wanted to be constructive but did not want to interfere in domestic politics.

He was speaking to Reuters two days ahead of US Vice President Kamala Harris’s trip to Vietnam and Singapore. The trip is set to show that the Biden administration is committed to a “free and open Indo-Pacific” and that the United States is in the region “to stay,” according to a senior administration official.

“We hope to make progress on cooperation, pandemic recovery, on digital economy, green economy and on cybersecurity,” said Balakrishnan. “It’s not just feel-good diplomacy, there’s substantive work to be done.”

Meanwhile, protests continued across Myanmar on Saturday, pressing the military rulers to return the country to democracy.

Social media posts showed protests in Mandalay and Kachin also urging the international community to recognise the shadow National Unity Government, made up mostly of the overthrown elected leaders of the country.

Source: Al Jazeera, Reuters