Kentucky and West Virginia move to limit transgender therapies

At least 11 US states have placed restrictions or outright bans on gender-affirming treatments for children.

A woman holds up a sign that reads, "It was never about a bathroom just as it was never about a water fountain."
A protester holds up a sign in protest against Kentucky’s Transgender Health Bill on March 29, comparing its restrictions to those seen during the time of racial segregation in the US [Timothy D. Easley/AP Photo]

Two states in the southern United States have advanced laws limiting access to gender-affirming therapies for transgender children, as part of a wave of Republican-led legislation critics decry as discriminatory and dangerous.

Kentucky and West Virginia join at least nine other states in implementing restrictions on treatments that leading medical groups like the American Academy of Pediatrics say can be necessary and even life-saving for transgender children.

But proponents of the restrictions argue that people under the age of 18 are too young to undergo gender-affirming treatments, which can range from measures like puberty blockers – which pause sexual development – to hormone treatment and surgery.

The first of Wednesday’s laws came in Kentucky, where a heavily Republican legislature used its supermajority to override an earlier veto from Democratic Governor Andy Beshear.

A portrait of Andy Beshear
Kentucky’s Republican-controlled legislature passed the law over a veto from its Democratic Governor Andy Beshear [File: Jon Cherry/Reuters]

Following a vote of 29 to eight in the state Senate, Kentucky’s House of Representatives passed the law along party lines, 76 to 23. The law also forces doctors to halt services for patients already undergoing treatment, unless a sudden end to care will harm the patient. In such cases, the law requires doctors to establish a timeline to end the treatment. Those restrictions are set to take effect in three months.

Kentucky’s bill will also bar schools from holding discussions of sexual orientation and gender identity, while educational districts must craft policies to ensure students use toilets corresponding to the gender on their birth certificates.

The debate in Kentucky’s state Capitol grew heated as the vote neared. State police later reported that 19 people were arrested for trespassing after protesting from the House gallery.

“We are denying families, their physicians and their therapists the right to make medically-informed decisions for their families,” Karen Berg, a Democratic state senator, said in opposition to the bill. Her 24-year-old child was a transgender activist who died by suicide in December.

Meanwhile, supporters of the bill say it protects children from undertaking gender-affirming treatments they might regret as adults.

“We cannot allow people to continue down the path of fantasy, to where they’re going to end up 10, 20, 30 years down the road and find themselves miserable from decisions that they made when they were young,” Shane Baker, Republican State Representative, said at a rally.

In praising the veto override, David Walls, executive director of The Family Foundation, said the bill puts “policy in alignment with the truth that every child is created as a male or female and deserves to be loved, treated with dignity and accepted for who they really are.”

On Wednesday in West Virginia, Republican Governor Jim Justice signed his state’s ban on gender-affirming therapies for children.

The law, set to take effect in January 2024, does include a rare exception: allowing prescribed puberty blockers and hormone therapy for teenagers shown to be at risk of self-harm. In those cases, patients must have parental consent and a diagnosis of severe gender dysphoria from two doctors.

West Virginia has the highest per capita rate of transgender young people in the US, according to a 2017 study from the Williams Institute, a think tank at the UCLA School of Law.

The laws in both Kentucky and West Virginia join a wave of Republican legislation across the country that critics denounce as an attack on LGBTQ+ rights. And they are both likely to be challenged in court.

Federal judges have already blocked the enforcement of laws restricting gender-affirming therapies in Alabama and Arkansas, and the American Civil Liberties Union of Kentucky has already announced it intends “to take this fight to the courts”.

Nearly two dozen states around the US are currently considering restrictions on gender-affirming care.

Source: Al Jazeera and news agencies