Five key takeaways from Donald Trump’s Manhattan arraignment

Ex-US president’s arraignment in New York was a relatively muted affair as Trump faced 34 felony charges.

The indictment against former United States President Donald Trump was unsealed in a New York City court on Tuesday, revealing 34 felony counts against the former Republican leader.

The 13-page document contained the latest revelations in a hush-money probe led by Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, and it cements Trump’s status as the first US president in history to face criminal charges.

Throughout the day, all eyes were on Trump, as he navigated protesters on the stoop of his Trump Tower skyscraper to get to the courthouse and be processed into the criminal justice system.

Here are five key takeaways from the historic court proceedings — and Trump’s reaction once he returned home to his Florida resort.

A close-up of Trump in a blue suit and red tie
Former US President Donald Trump arrives at Trump Tower on April 3, ahead of Tuesday’s court hearing [Yuki Iwamura/AP Photo]

Trump’s much-anticipated surrender was relatively muted

A little after 1:00pm Eastern Time (17:00 GMT), the former president left his penthouse residence at Trump Tower to head to Lower Manhattan for his court date.

He waved to supporters as he made his commute, arriving at the Manhattan Criminal Court shortly thereafter. There was no perp walk, no handcuffs and no mug shot.

After he was fingerprinted and processed, an uncharacteristically quiet Trump sat between his lawyers to hear the charges laid against him. He pleaded not guilty to all 34 felony counts.

At one point during the proceedings, New York Judge Juan Merchan warned Trump against becoming “disruptive”. Trump acknowledged the judge’s remarks.

The court appearance took less than an hour. Trump departed in his motorcade without stopping to speak to the press.

Daniels, with long blonde hair, leans slightly, and holds a black-t-shirt up (most of which is cut off by the camera) looking into the camera
A payment to adult film actor Stormy Daniels is at the centre of the hush-money probe in New York [File: Eduardo Munoz/Reuters]

Charges go beyond Stormy Daniels payment

At Trump’s arraignment, the indictment against the ex-president was unsealed, revealing 34 felony charges of falsifying business records.

The Manhattan grand jury’s investigation was previously thought to centre around $130,000 allegedly paid to the adult film star Stormy Daniels, to buy her silence in the lead-up to the 2016 presidential election.

At the time, Daniels claimed she and then-presidential candidate Trump had an extramarital affair.

But the Manhattan District Attorney’s office unveiled a much broader scope in its charges, accusing the former president of “repeatedly and fraudulently” falsifying records to conceal “damaging information from the voting public”.

It described alleged “catch and kill” schemes, accusing Trump of collaborating with the head of American Media Inc (AMI) to buy and suppress coverage that might blemish his public image.

Among the stories allegedly suppressed were that of a doorman, who claimed to know of a child fathered out of wedlock, and that of an affair with former Playboy model Karen McDougal.

A woman holds up a hand-drawn sign showing Trump behind bars
Demonstrators supporting Trump’s prosecution gather outside the Manhattan Criminal Court on Tuesday [Shannon Stapleton/Reuters]

No repeat of January 6 violence

Outside the Trump Tower skyscraper and the Manhattan Criminal Court, hundreds of protesters gathered to voice their support either for the prosecution or for Trump.

But aside from some minor clashes between the different camps, the demonstrations ultimately ended peacefully, despite lingering concerns about political violence following the 2021 Capitol attack.

That incident saw Trump supporters launch a deadly assault on the seat of the US Congress on January 6, 2021, as a joint session was underway to certify the results of the 2020 presidential elections.

Trump had been accused of riling up his supporters prior to the attack. And ahead of Tuesday’s arraignment, he took to social media to once again call on his backers to rise up on his behalf.

“The far & away leading Republican candidate and former president of the United States of America will be arrested,” he wrote in all caps on Truth Social on March 18. “Protest, take our nation back!”

However, with 35,000 New York City police officers in uniform for Tuesday’s arraignment, no significant violence was reported, though Georgia Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene claimed to be “swarmed” by anti-Trump protesters.

Marjorie Taylor Greene in aviator sunglasses, speaking into the mouthpiece of a bullhorn
Georgia Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene speaks outside the Manhattan Criminal Court ahead of Trump’s appearance [Caitlin Ochs/Reuters]

Political persecution or holding the powerful to account?

Reactions to Trump’s arraignment were split along party lines, with Republicans decrying an abuse of the legal system and Democrats calling for the powerful to be held to account.

“No one is above the law, no matter how rich or powerful they are,” Michigan Representative Rashida Tlaib said in a statement, repeating a common refrain among Democrats.

But Republicans expressed outrage at what they considered a weaponisation of the legal system for political purposes. Many echoed Trump’s claims that the prosecution was intended to derail the Republican leader’s bid for reelection in 2024.

“Put aside for a moment whether you like Trump or don’t like him, whether you’re for him or not for him. Today is a bad day for all of us. Today American politics crosses a line that it’s never going to come back from,” said Florida Senator Marco Rubio, who faced Trump as a Republican candidate in the 2016 presidential election.

“After today, every prosecutor in America who wants to make a name for themselves now is going to have permission to basically go after someone in the other party.”

Trump at a podium that reads: "Text Trump to 88022, Trump, Make America Great Again"
Former President Donald Trump addresses supporters at his Mar-a-Lago resort on Tuesday, after his arraignment [Marco Bello/Reuters]

Trump’s Mar-a-Lago speech goes broad, not specific

Ending his day at his Mar-a-Lago residence in Palm Beach, Florida, Trump held a speech in the resort’s ballroom for supporters and allies, including My Pillow CEO Michael Lindell and Georgia Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene.

But rather than addressing the specifics of Tuesday’s indictment, Trump’s remarks covered a broad range of familiar complaints — from the decline he perceives in US society to the biased treatment he allegedly receives from prosecutors.

“Incredibly, we are now a failing nation. We are a nation in decline. And now these radical left lunatics want to interfere with our elections by using law enforcement. We can’t let that happen,” he told the crowd.

But while he talked about everything from his alleged mishandling of confidential documents to the Georgia election probe, Trump reserved particular criticism for Manhattan District Attorney Bragg and the judge in Tuesday’s proceedings, Merchan.

“I have a Trump-hating judge with a Trump-hating wife and family whose daughter worked for Kamala Harris,” he said, referring to the Democratic vice president.

Source: Al Jazeera